Renovating an Older York Home: What Might Be Behind the Plaster, Avenna Journal

Journal · Renovation

Renovating an Older York Home: What Might Be Behind the Plaster

Christie Moreira · 5 min read

Older York homes have real character, and a few common surprises. What to plan for when you open up walls in a house built before the 1970s.

We love older York homes. Plaster walls, real wood trim, rooms with some personality. But when you renovate a house that's been around for generations, you're also inheriting every choice made by every owner before you. Here's what we plan for.

Older wiring

Some older homes still have early wiring, like knob-and-tube, or circuits that were added on over the years without much of a plan. Wiring like this may not be grounded and wasn't built for today's kitchens and electronics. Have a licensed electrician look before you budget, and know that some insurance companies ask about older wiring too.

Lead paint

If a home was built before 1978, assume there may be lead paint under the newer layers. Federal rules require contractors who disturb painted surfaces in those homes to be certified and to use lead-safe work practices. It affects how demolition, sanding and cleanup are done, so it belongs in the plan from day one.

Plumbing that's had a long life

Older galvanized supply lines can narrow inside over time. Cast iron drains can crack. You may not see either problem until a wall or floor is open, so give plumbing its own line in the contingency.

Walls that aren't quite straight

Plaster over lath is solid, but houses settle. Expect to shim, scribe and adjust when new cabinets, tile or trim meet old walls. It's normal. It just takes time.

Insulation and air leaks

Many older homes have little or no insulation in exterior walls and lots of small air leaks. When walls are open is the easiest time to improve that.

How we plan for it

  • Walk the house with the trades who'll actually do the work.
  • Separate "known" work from "might find" work in the budget.
  • Hold a real contingency and decide in advance what gets cut if you need it.
  • Keep the character pieces worth saving on a list so nobody tears them out by accident.

Have an older home in mind? Let's walk it together before you set the budget.

— Christie, founder of Avenna Homes

Avenna Homes LLC · York, Pennsylvania · PA Home Improvement Contractor Registration PA217609 · Maryland MHIC License 05-170382 · 717-881-7299